The Headless Horseman

The Headless Horseman
The Headless Horseman
1
The Headless Horseman – Holo

The Headless Horseman

#232Holo

$263.02

Enchanted
88.3% of set value
2
The Headless Horseman – Cold Foil

The Headless Horseman

#125Cold Foil

$19.55

Legendary
6.6% of set value
3
The Headless Horseman – Normal

The Headless Horseman

#125Normal

$13.46

Legendary
4.5% of set value
Total Card Value
$297.95
4 cards across all sets
Find great deals on eBay!
We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
Cards (4)Price ListAnalytics
The Headless Horseman

#125

Whispers in the Well
Legendary

Normal: $13.46

Cold Foil: $19.55

The Headless Horseman

#174

Whispers in the Well
Super Rare

Normal: $0.37

Cold Foil: $1.20

The Headless Horseman

#194

Whispers in the Well
Common

Normal: $0.09

Cold Foil: $0.26

The Headless Horseman

#232

Whispers in the Well
Enchanted

Holo: $263.02

 

Prices shown assume Near Mint condition and are indicative only, market prices may vary.
Price data last updated on August 16, 2026.