Top 5 Most Expensive The Headless Horseman Cards

(July 2026)
Discover the most valuable The Headless Horseman cards. These premium cards represent the highest market values, including rare holofoils, secret rares, and special variants that collectors prize most.
1

Whispers in the Well#232
Holo

$237.27

Whispers in the Well#232
Holo

$237.27
Set
Whispers in the Well
Artist
Rubin Chung
Rarity

Enchanted

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
2

Whispers in the Well#125
Cold Foil

$20.09

Whispers in the Well#125
Cold Foil

$20.09
Set
Whispers in the Well
Artist
Andrew Chesworth
Rarity

Legendary

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
3

Whispers in the Well#125
Normal

$17.71

Whispers in the Well#125
Normal

$17.71
Set
Whispers in the Well
Artist
Andrew Chesworth
Rarity

Legendary

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
4

Whispers in the Well#174
Cold Foil

$1.24

Whispers in the Well#174
Cold Foil

$1.24
Set
Whispers in the Well
Artist
Marcel Berg
Rarity

Super Rare

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
5

Whispers in the Well#174
Normal

$0.27

Whispers in the Well#174
Normal

$0.27
Set
Whispers in the Well
Artist
Marcel Berg
Rarity

Super Rare

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.

Prices shown assume Near Mint condition and are indicative only, market prices may vary.
Price data last updated on July 2, 2026.