Top 5 Most Expensive Pegasus Cards

(July 2026)
Discover the most valuable Pegasus cards. These premium cards represent the highest market values, including rare holofoils, secret rares, and special variants that collectors prize most.
1

Challenge Promos 2#5
Holo

$141.42

Challenge Promos 2#5
Holo

$141.42
Set
Challenge Promos 2
Artist
Kenneth Anderson
Rarity

Promo

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
2

Challenge Promos 2#5
Normal

$45.01

Challenge Promos 2#5
Normal

$45.01
Set
Challenge Promos 2
Artist
Kenneth Anderson
Rarity

Promo

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
3

Fabled#212
Holo

$6.96

Fabled#212
Holo

$6.96
Set
Fabled
Artist
Brian Weisz
Rarity

Epic

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
4

Ursula's Return#83
Cold Foil

$0.40

Ursula's Return#83
Cold Foil

$0.40
Set
Ursula's Return
Artist
Brian Weisz
Rarity

Uncommon

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
5

Ursula's Return#84
Cold Foil

$0.27

Ursula's Return#84
Cold Foil

$0.27
Set
Ursula's Return
Artist
Brian Weisz
Rarity

Common

Estimated Pull Rate

Not available

Shop on eBay
iWe may earn a commission from qualifying purchases through affiliate links at no extra cost to you.

Prices shown assume Near Mint condition and are indicative only, market prices may vary.
Price data last updated on July 2, 2026.